March 13, 2008

"Success Only Has Value If Failure Is An Option"

The title quote was something a friend said to me while we were discussing the sorry state of education. The discussion itself was brought on by a remark that Americans are the "smarties", a position which I think is in danger (as if we aren't already way down the list).

Truly, I don't find an actual interest in teaching anymore - just ensuring everyone feels good about themselves and no one is offended...doesn't leave any time for actual curriculum. (Yes, I realize there are teachers out there fighting the good fight, but they are in the minority. Far too many of their colleagues are fighting to stop home schooling and/or any other options parents might have to ensure a quality education for their children)


I then referenced the unbelievably weak AIMS test, and how neutered it has become. You can get a bit of a take on it, and a bit of history, from Laurie Roberts.

It is disgusting that so many children can't pass such a basic test - and that teachers seem incapable of teaching them.

It is even worse that we continue to find ways to excuse it and allow these children out into the world, knowing they are ill-equipped to handle it.

But, why should they put forth the effort when there simply are no consequences?

"Success only has value if failure is an option"

Posted by Vox at 12:53 PM | Comments (2)